The Quiet Standards Framework
A standard for software that respects attention.
Accessibility has WCAG. Privacy has GDPR. Hardware has the Calm Tech Institute. The Quiet Standards Framework covers how software treats your attention, your data and your right to leave, and it’s written so two independent auditors reach the same result.
The framework in numbers
Seven domains
01 · 23 criteria · 6 gates
Attention
Design for the smallest possible amount of your attention
- No push notifications unless user-configured. Marketing/re-engagement = auto-fail.
- No infinite scroll. Feeds must terminate or paginate.
- No streaks, badges, leaderboards, or penalties for non-use.
- Default notifications are the minimum state. User opts in, not out.
02 · 18 criteria · 5 gates
Data Sovereignty
Your data belongs to you
- Full data export in open format (JSON, CSV, XML) within 3 clicks.
- Export includes ALL user-generated content, metadata, and history.
- Never sells or shares data with advertisers or data brokers.
- Account deletion is complete, permanent, and in-app.
03 · 16 criteria · 5 gates
Honesty
Amplify the best of people and technology without confusing the two
- No confirmshaming, roach motels, or bait-and-switch.
- Cancellation flow has no more steps than the signup flow.
- Monetization model stated plainly on marketing site and in-app.
- AI-generated content clearly labeled and distinguishable.
04 · 12 criteria · 4 gates
Departure
Solve the problem, then get out of your way
- No retention dialogs or emotional appeals when closing the app.
- Subscription cancellable entirely in-app. No phone calls or letters.
- After cancellation, data remains accessible and exportable for 30+ days.
- Documented plan for user data if company shuts down.
05 · 14 criteria · 3 gates
Respect
Respect your time and social norms
- No sensor access without explicit, revocable consent.
- Default notification times restricted to 8AM–9PM user-local.
- No crypto mining or unauthorized device resource usage.
- Just-in-time permission requests only, not all at first launch.
06 · 12 criteria · 3 gates
Durability
Software degrades gracefully
- WCAG 2.1 Level AA for all primary user flows.
- Minimum 44×44px touch targets. Fully keyboard-navigable.
- Uses open web standards. No proprietary plugins for core function.
- Public changelog and stated support policy.
07 · 9 criteria · 1 gate
Governance
Transparent and verifiable
- Privacy policy exists, accessible in-app, updated within 12 months.
- Plain-language privacy summary at 8th-grade reading level.
- All third-party SDKs and trackers identified with data practices.
- Funding sources publicly disclosed.
Scoring
Three tiers
- QSF Verified57+ points (40%)Meets baseline ethical standards. No exploitative patterns. All 27 must-pass criteria satisfied.
- QSF Certified86+ points (60%)Demonstrates active commitment to user respect across all domains. Requires domain minimums: strong notification design can’t make up for weak data practices.
- QSF Exemplary114+ points (80%)Industry-leading attention-respecting software. Suitable as a reference implementation for others building in this space.
How criteria are checked
Four kinds of evidence
Technical Inspection (T)
Auditor examines the running application, source code, or network traffic.
Documentation Review (D)
Auditor reviews published policies, changelogs, or support documentation.
User Journey Walkthrough (U)
Auditor completes a specific user flow and records the experience step by step.
Declarative Attestation (A)
Company attests to practices that cannot be externally verified. False attestation voids certification.
Where it fits
The work it sits beside
Good work on ethical technology already exists in advocacy, hardware certification, privacy law, accessibility and process standards. The framework adds a product-level, auditable test for software, meant to sit beside the others.
- WCAGAuditable standard, accessibilityThe gold standard for auditable design criteria. Proves this model works. It covers disability access only, leaving out attention, data sovereignty, dark patterns and engagement ethics.
- Calm Tech Institute81-point certification, hardwareEvaluates physical products across materials, light, and sound. Certified reMarkable, Mudita, Daylight Computer. No coverage for software UX, data portability, or engagement loops.
- GDPR Certification MarksAuditable certification, data consentEuroPriSe and similar schemes certify data protection compliance. Covers consent-related dark patterns but not engagement design, notification ethics, or graceful offboarding.
- Center for Humane TechnologyAdvocacy, awarenessBuilt massive public awareness around attention exploitation. Publishes frameworks and toolkits. Does not certify products or offer an auditable standard.
- IEEE 7000Process standard, design processTells organizations how to incorporate ethics into design. Audits the process, not the product. Cannot tell you whether an app’s notifications respect your dinner.
- Norwegian Consumer CouncilPolicy report, regulation“Breaking Free” identifies enshittification and pushes for the EU Digital Fairness Act. It operates at the policy level, with no engineering criteria a developer can test against.
Use it
The specification is open, and the self-audit skill is free to run with Claude Code. For a guided audit of your product, the studio can help.
